The United States has proposed discussing NATO’s rules and the deployment of troops in Europe as part of negotiations to end Russia’s war against Ukraine. The move brings the future of European security into peace talks, as Moscow presses for a rollback of NATO’s military presence and European governments weigh how to respond.
Russia seeks a rollback to 1997
US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner presented Moscow’s proposal to European partners and urged them to consider it, according to Bloomberg reports cited by Romanian media. Russia wants NATO’s military presence returned to its 1997 level, which would mean withdrawing troops and equipment from at least 16 of the alliance’s 32 members. The countries named include Romania, the Baltic states, Finland, Sweden and Albania.
In return, Moscow has proposed reducing its military presence in Kaliningrad and Belarus. Analysts cited in one report viewed the Kaliningrad offer with scepticism: Russia is proposing to pull back forces, not give up the territory.
At talks in Abu Dhabi on November 11, the Russian delegation, led by presidential adviser Vladimir Medinsky, also sought limits on NATO cooperation with Ukraine and other former Soviet republics. Moscow asked Ukraine to abandon its goal of joining NATO, which is written into the country’s constitution, the reports said. Russia has made similar demands before: the Biden administration and its allies rejected them in late 2021, shortly before the full-scale invasion.
Europe agrees to take part
European governments have argued that Russia should first stop hostilities before negotiations turn to troop deployments or NATO’s future. But leaders agreed to send representatives to technical consultations, concerned that staying out could leave them excluded from decisions on European security. They also agreed to form a group of security advisers representing the EU and Germany, France, the UK, Italy and Poland.
Some European leaders rejected the US proposals, while some reportedly considered whether Ukraine could join NATO with altered borders if Kyiv agreed. US negotiators have also asked Kyiv whether it would cede Donbas to Russia in exchange for NATO membership, according to the reports.
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has been reported as willing to consider US security proposals. Kyiv is seeking concrete guarantees on NATO and EU membership, a strong Ukrainian army and funding for post-war reconstruction. Lithuania’s foreign minister, Kęstutis Budrys, said NATO’s eastern flank was not negotiable and there could be no spheres of influence.
Berlin talks are next
Witkoff and Kushner are scheduled to meet Ukrainian and European representatives in Berlin on November 19 to discuss security guarantees for Kyiv after the war. No outcome of that meeting has yet been reported.
The debate also touches on NATO’s open-door policy. Article 10 of the North Atlantic Treaty says new members are admitted by agreement among alliance members, with no role for a country outside NATO in that decision.




Comments
To comment, sign in or create an account. Sign in Create an account
No comments yet.