A senior US defence official criticised Ukrainian strikes deep inside Russia at a meeting in Brussels on November 17, saying they had not helped bring the war to an end or halt Russian advances. German and British defence ministers pushed back, defending Ukraine’s ability to choose how it fights.

Elbridge Colby, the US deputy assistant secretary of defence for policy, spoke at a meeting of the Ukraine Defense Contact Group, which brings together about 40 countries supporting Kyiv. He argued that US support should focus on helping Ukraine hold the front line and make gains where possible, rather than expanding attacks deep inside Russia.

Colby questions the impact of deep strikes

Colby said the US assessment was that deep strikes had not helped end the war or stop Russian progress on the battlefield. He also said attacks on civilian infrastructure, including facilities belonging to Wildberries, a major Russian online retailer, had probably strengthened Russian public resolve and the Kremlin’s willingness to escalate. His remarks described an assessment, not a confirmed effect of the strikes.

He did not argue that Ukraine should be forced to fight with its hands tied. Instead, Colby said support should strengthen Ukraine’s ability to hold the front and, where possible, gain ground. He also pointed to medium-range strikes that disrupt Russian logistics as a more effective focus for US support. Colby said Ukraine had regained more territory than it lost in October for the second month in a row, while Russian forces had suffered their largest monthly losses of the war.

Allies challenge the emphasis

German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius said attention should be directed instead at Russian attacks on civilian, energy, water and heating infrastructure in Ukraine. He argued that strikes on lawful military and dual-use targets in Russia should not be the focus of criticism, and described Russia’s attacks as a form of terrorism.

British Defence Minister Wes Streeting said it was not for others to tell Ukraine how to wage its war. He said deep strikes had helped weaken Russia’s war effort, buy time and save lives. NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte said allies agreed Ukraine should do everything it could to defend itself from Russian attacks. Ukrainian Defence Minister Yevheniy Khmara also said Ukraine had the right to defend itself and retaliate.

The meeting brought the disagreement into the open: Colby argued for a stronger focus on the front line and medium-range attacks, while the British and German ministers defended Ukraine’s latitude to strike Russian targets. The officials’ remarks did not establish that US policy or military assistance had changed.