Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court president Edson Fachin has shared police reports on four of the court’s justices, whose names appeared in messages on the phone of Banco Master owner Daniel Vorcaro. Each justice received only the material relating to their own case.

Reports by Estadão and Brasil 247 said the Federal Police (PF) selected references to Alexandre de Moraes, Dias Toffoli, Kassio Nunes Marques and André Mendonça for legal assessment. The reports do not establish wrongdoing, and the justices are not thereby formally under investigation. The next step is for prosecutors to assess whether the material warrants further action.

Accounts differ on how many justices were mentioned

Estadão reported that the PF recorded references to all 10 current members of the court. SBT News said the number had not been confirmed, while reporting an expectation that at least six justices were mentioned. The reports do not describe what the messages said. The four cases selected for legal assessment should therefore not be confused with the total number of justices whose names may appear in the material.

Reports were rewritten after an earlier draft

PF director-general Andrei Rodrigues delivered the complete material to Fachin on the night of November 18. The first version of the reports highlighted Moraes, Toffoli and Nunes Marques; the revised version also included Mendonça. Estadão and SBT News reported that the earlier version was discarded and two delegates involved in preparing it were removed from leadership posts in the investigation.

Rodrigues said the reports had to be redone because they did not meet parameters set by the Supreme Court. He described the delegates’ removal as the result of a breach of trust and denied that it was motivated by the reports’ contents.

The reports are to be assessed by Prosecutor-General Paulo Gonet and the team handling the Banco Master case. Accounts differed on when the Prosecutor-General’s Office (PGR) received the material: Exame said it had not arrived by early afternoon on November 19, while later reports by Estadão and SBT News said the full material had been sent or was available to the office. Brasil 247 said it would be forwarded.

The PGR has 15 days from formal receipt to respond, though the deadline is administrative and can pass without an automatic penalty. Its view will not bind the court’s full bench, which decides on investigative measures involving its members. A reference to a justice in seized material, by itself, does not show misconduct or mean that an investigation has been opened.